What helped this sometimes dazzling piece to succeed was Hagen's clever way of introducing new ideas or textures
every few bars.
... Much Ado served as a nifty appetizer to a carefully designed evening of good vibrations. This was, after all, the season-opener. [Nashville Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Kenneth Schermerhorn.]
— Alan Bostick, The Tennessean, 9/5/03
An uncommonly audacious romp. ...Hagen's sound is mostly large and rich, marked by a steady pulse driving intricately lively textures that recall both the Renaissance lute and Charlie Parker's saxophone.
Amid this lusty turbulence swim long, strong brass melodies that rise, and disappear, and rise again. Hagen quotes a line from Shakespeare's comedy that also fits his own work: 'What a merry, exhilarating play.'
Much Ado was a beautifully chosen piece for this orchestra in this hall, filling the venue's space with vital energy. [Nashville Symphony; Schermerhorn.]
— Marcel Smith, Nashville Scene, September 11-17, 2003
Hagen's Much Ado lived up to its title in all the wrong ways. The composer kept the orchestra extremely busy, but with musical activities that seemed third hand; one soaring french
horn passage (the sort you hear in inspirational moments of corny movies) was repeated three [sic] times, even though once was enough to kill the piece's credibility. [Curtis Symphony conducted by Robert Spano.]
— David Patrick Stearns, The Philadelphia Inquirer, 5/3/00
The sweeping violins and noble horns of Mr. Hagen's Much Ado were reminiscent of John Williams' movie scores. Maybe Mr. Hagen should have a go at it. [Dallas Symphony, conducted by Andrew Litton.]
— Olin Chism, The Dallas Morning News, 6/27/03